GuideStar International's Blog

June 2, 2010

Help for Haiti’s next Generation from Global Society

Filed under: Aid Effectiveness,civil society,Philanthropy — guidestarinternational @ 15:25
Tags: ,

Buzz Schmidt, Founder & Chair, GuideStar International

By Buzz Schmidt, Founder & Chair, GuideStar International

European Foundation Week Session: Help for Haiti’s next Generation from Global Society- Organised by SOS Children’s Villages, 1st June 2010

This workshop was led by SOS Children’s Villages, a global NGO (30,000 associates) that supports kids in 109 countries through safe living and meeting spaces (villages).  SOS states that it is the best established NGO operating in Haiti.  Half of the 26 people in the room were representatives of SOS offices in European countries.   The other attendees were primarily European representatives of other NGOs – Accion, Concern Worldwidebetterplace.org (German online giving platform for 2000 causes) Boy Scouts, Glocalist (advocacy newspaper in Berlin) and TSG.  A representative of the InterAmerican Development Bank (focused on funding infrastructure) also attended.

Brief input papers on the Haiti’s status were presented by SOS staff.  There was overall an sense that major issues still confront the recovery.  Many people and NGOs are already leaving.  The media left two months ago. People are still suffering terribly.  This input was followed by a roundtable discussion about coordination, progress, long-term vision, global input versus local initiative, etc.   The major questions are – how can we keep Haiti top of mind; how can one establish the kind of vision and deliverables that will keep donors engaged when legitimacy requires national Haitian control of its own future; how do you rebuild capacity of public sector to lead the rebuilding effort; how do you coordinate various recovery and building efforts?

Implications for TechSoup Global: The notion of constructing a more conducive environment and infrastructure to support indigenous CSOs did not arise and the flow of the conversation prevented me from explicitly raising and exploring it.  But this infrastructure would certainly be a central feature in the development of a sustainable, self-promoting society in Haiti and countries like it.  But Haiti, itself, continues to be a country that will be disproportionately visible, and a successful TSG/GSI intervention could be very useful for our reputation and organization CV.   For many excellent reasons, we lack a sense of urgency about this opportunity/need.  We are not alone as other organizations have difficulty being properly responsive in these types of situations.  But it does underscore the need to get our various offerings synchronized and proposition better-defined so that a TSG intervention for this type of situation is possible.

March 25, 2010

Does aid money always end up in the right hands?: Investigation of the 1980s famine relief appeal

Filed under: Accountability,Aid Effectiveness,CSO reporting,Transparency — guidestarinternational @ 09:10
Tags: , ,

Read Time Magazine’s report on the humanitarian aid industry in Africa following a BBC report, which said that 95% of the millions of aid dollars given for Ethiopian famine relief efforts in the 1980s ended up in the hands of rebels. Both reports claimed that most of the aid money gathered from this massive appeal to the public was used to fund weapons and help rebels seize control of the government. As reports continue to be dug up, which heightens wariness of giving for good causes, the public will want to hear about the success and failures of aid efforts not only from government and CSOs who make information about the use of aid more transparent, but also from those who have actually benefitted and those who have not.



March 10, 2010

Can citizen philanthropists, CSOs and governments find a way to work together?

Filed under: Aid Effectiveness,Philanthropy,volunteering — guidestarinternational @ 11:18
Tags:

Citizens around the world are starting to take more control of their giving at home and abroad. They want to dictate who they give to, what they give and want more direct contact with the individuals that they help to maximise the effectiveness of their assistance. This has led to an increase in what is now coined ‘Citizen Philanthropy’, and such activity is being driven in part due to frustration caused by CSO and government failure to respond quickly and transparently, but also because of new and accessible ICT resources.  These citizens aim for tangible results from their actions and do not solely rely on CSOs and governments to decide how donations should be used. However, one study by the Wolfensohn Centre for Development entitled Do Philanthropic Citizens Behave Like Governments? Internet-Based Platforms and the Diffusion of International Private Aid compared KIVA and Global Giving (two citizen philanthropic websites) and found that ‘private aid and official aid are complementary: official aid supports countries, private aid supports people’.

Therefore, as development assistance becomes even more fragmented there should be a better way for the citizen philanthropist, the CSO and governments to understand each other’s role and partner where necessary.  As individuals take control of their philanthropy (See Volunteers fed up with slow pace of multinational relief effort in Haiti choose to go it alone as an example of this) and use intermediaries like Citizen Effect and various social networking sites to correspond directly with recipients, conversations about philanthropy will increasingly be not only about and among governments and registered CSOs but about and among the people who have benefited, those citizens who have individually and collectively helped and their related networks. Accessible technology and increased access to information from governments and CSOs should also enable everyone to understand how the work of one citizen has helped someone in need as well as supported the work of CSOs or/and governments.

February 10, 2010

Coorporation between Chinese and African civil society organisations

Filed under: Aid Effectiveness,civil society — guidestarinternational @ 14:38
Tags: , , ,

By Keisha Taylor

The civil society sector in China differs from that found in African countries.  In China there is a high level of national government influence in CSO activities, while CSOs in many African countries depend on aid from foreign donors. The article Civil Society Participation and China-Africa cooperation examines collaborative efforts being pursued by the Chinese government and governments in Africa to increase effectiveness of civil society organisations. The article was written following the China–Africa Civil Society Dialogue conference hosted by the Forum on China and African Coorporation (FOCAC).

February 9, 2010

Haiti: ‘A Republic of NGOs’ – but how do all these local NGOs help?

Filed under: Accountability,Aid Effectiveness,Philanthropy — guidestarinternational @ 16:18
Tags: , , ,

By Keisha Taylor

Did you know that Haiti has the highest number of local NGOs per capita in the world? It has been coined ‘A Republic of NGOs’ because of it. Before this year’s earthquake, 3000 local NGOs in a population of 10 million people were operating in Haiti, which is one of the poorest countries in the world due to its colonial past, coups, crippling debt, and susceptibility to natural disasters. It follows that the proliferation of local NGOs is understandable. NGOs help to provide services that the government won’t or don’t have the capacity to provide. However, the article Why Haiti Should Beware Professional Do-Gooders examines how the increase of foreign donors and NGOs in Haiti, though providing much need assistance, is also capable of limiting sovereignty and government capacity, which can thwarts overall development efforts. Giving resources that aren’t needed can cripple the local economy (as was the case where donated clothes in Zambia crippled the local textile industry).  The simple concept of matching needs with resources must be applied to collaborative efforts of donors, NGOs and very importantly the Haitian government. Only through working together, in a transparent and accountable manner, will long term development goals be achieved and NGOs must ensure that regardless of good intentions, their actions help and not hinder this process.

November 26, 2009

Caroline Neligan Presents the GuideStar Model to Colombian Civil Society

At the invitation of Conexion Colombia Caroline travelled to Bogota, Colombia from the 16-19 November 2009 to present the GuideStar model to a group of over 200 NGO representatives. The meeting, titled ‘Fundraising and Innovation for NGOs’ explored a range of initiatives that promote the work of NGOs and connect them to donors and other stakeholders at national and international levels. A summary can be read in Spanish and English.

César Bocanegra, Angela Escallón, Caroline Neligan, John Hecklinger

During her visit, Caroline also met with several leading organisations supporting social development and Colombian civil society:

Conexion Colombia channels resources from all around the world to a portfolio of Colombian NGOs and foundations and links diaspora Colombians to their country through a range of information services.

Compartamos con Colombia, is an NGO that promotes the Colombian nonprofit sector through strategic support and capacity building, the promotion of philanthropy and social investment, and by raising awareness of the importance of social responsibility with young entrpreneurs.

The Presidential Agency for Social Action and International Cooperation, Accion Social, coordinates, promotes and carries out international cooperation policies, plans and projects which contribute to the social and economic development of Colombia, and to reducing the poverty of Colombians who have been affected by violence, illicit crops and who live in conditions of vulnerability.

And last but not least, ONG por la Transparencia (NGOs for Transparency) seeks to increase NGO visibility and make publicly available information that seeks to strengthen the credibility of the sector and increase public support for the work of these important organisations.

There was significant interest in how GuideStar might help illuminate the work of Colombian NGOs and promote a culture of transparency and information that will help connect Colombians both at home and abroad with national NGOs and the communities in which they work. We look forward to continuing these initial conversations.

November 24, 2009

Are CSOs the Missing Piece of the Puzzle?

by Keisha Taylor

Is the institutional role of CSOs in the aid effectiveness agenda truly recognised? Should donors and government provide a more enabling environment for CSOs to improve their efficiency? Shouldn’t CSOs be viewed as more than simply an avenue for the delivery of services? These are some of the questions addressed in the paper entitled “The  Missing Piece of the Puzzle: The institutional importance of CSOs in the development effectiveness agenda” as it seeks to explain why such information must be included in any analysis of development effectiveness.

« Previous Page

Theme: Rubric. Blog at WordPress.com.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.